Mode
Text Size
Log in / Sign up

Relational trust and structural support influence women's disclosure of domestic abuse to healthcare professionalsKey Factors Influence Women Sharing Domestic Abuse with Healthcare Providers

AI-generated summary of the cited source, checked by automated accuracy review. How we work

Key Takeaway
Note that disclosure of domestic abuse requires both relational trust and structural support to ensure effective outcomes.

This systematic literature review synthesizes the factors influencing women's disclosure of domestic abuse to healthcare professionals and the preparedness of providers to identify and respond. The review identifies disclosure as a relational and socially mediated process influenced by trust, perceived safety, validation, confidentiality, and continuity of care. Additionally, the concept of borrowed trust via social networks was identified as a factor influencing a woman's willingness to engage with providers.

Healthcare professional preparedness is determined by competence, confidence, emotional readiness, clarity of safeguarding responsibilities, and access to referral pathways. Conversely, structural constraints such as limited consultation time, workload pressures, and organizational ambiguity were found to constrain effective responses. The authors note that disclosure alone does not ensure improved outcomes when system readiness is inadequate.

Clinical practice may benefit from multilevel strategies to improve outcomes. These include organizational leadership, protected time for consultations, clear referral systems, and alignment across both relational and structural domains. The findings suggest that addressing both the patient's need for a safe environment and the provider's need for structural support is necessary for effective intervention.

This review looked at what helps women feel safe enough to share experiences of domestic abuse with healthcare professionals. The researchers found that disclosure is a social process. It depends heavily on trust, feeling safe, being validated, and knowing that their information will remain confidential. Sometimes, women rely on "borrowed trust" from their social networks to feel comfortable speaking up.

On the other side, the study looked at how prepared healthcare workers are to help. A provider's ability to respond depends on their competence, confidence, and emotional readiness. They also need clear rules on their responsibilities and easy access to referral paths. When these internal factors are missing, it can be harder for a patient to feel safe sharing.

Finally, the study noted that structural issues like high workloads and limited time can make it harder for staff to provide a good response. It is important to note that a woman sharing her story only leads to better outcomes if the healthcare system is actually ready to support her. Improving care requires both a trusting relationship and a well-organized system.

What this means for you:
Women's disclosure of abuse depends on both personal trust and the healthcare system's readiness to respond.

Common questions

What makes a woman more likely to share domestic abuse with a doctor?

A woman's decision to share is often a social process. It is influenced by factors like trust, feeling safe, receiving validation, and knowing her information is confidential. She may also rely on "borrowed trust" from her own social networks to feel comfortable sharing her experience with a healthcare professional.

What makes a healthcare provider better prepared to help?

A provider's preparedness is determined by their competence, confidence, and emotional readiness. They also need clear knowledge of their safeguarding responsibilities and easy access to referral pathways to provide an effective response to a patient who discloses domestic abuse.

How do workplace issues affect the response to domestic abuse?

Structural factors can limit how well a provider can help. These include high workload pressures, limited consultation time, and organizational ambiguity. For a disclosure to lead to a good outcome, the system must be ready to support the patient beyond just the initial conversation.

Study Details

Study typeMeta analysis
EvidenceLevel 1
PublishedOct 2026
View Original Abstract ↓
Domestic abuse (DA) is a significant public health and human rights issue with profound physical, psychological, and social consequences. Healthcare settings provide important opportunities for identification and support; however, disclosure by women remains inconsistent, and healthcare professionals’ readiness to identify and respond varies widely. This qualitative systematic review synthesised evidence examining factors influencing women's disclosure of DA within healthcare contexts and healthcare professionals’ preparedness to respond. A systematic search of MEDLINE, Embase, CINAHL, PsycINFO, and Scopus was conducted for studies published between 2000 and 2023. Additional studies were identified through reference searching. The review followed PRISMA guidance and was informed by the SPIDER framework. Qualitative and mixed-methods studies with extractable qualitative findings were included. Methodological quality was appraised using the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklist. Findings were synthesised narratively and interpreted using a socio-ecological model to capture multilevel influences on disclosure and response. Disclosure emerged as a relational and socially mediated process shaped by trust, perceived safety, validation, confidentiality, and continuity of care. Forms of “borrowed trust,” mediated through social networks, influenced women's willingness to engage. Healthcare professionals’ preparedness was determined by competence, confidence, emotional readiness, clarity of safeguarding responsibilities, and access to referral pathways. Structural factors, including limited consultation time, workload pressures, and organisational ambiguity, constrained effective response. Importantly, disclosure alone did not ensure improved outcomes where system readiness was inadequate. Improving responses to DA requires multilevel strategies extending beyond individual training. Sustainable progress depends on organisational leadership, protected time, clear referral systems, and alignment across relational and structural domains to support safe disclosure and meaningful intervention.
Free Newsletter

Clinical research that matters. Delivered to your inbox.

Join thousands of clinicians and researchers. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.