This observational cohort study evaluated Berrylyzer, a novel end-to-end variant prioritization system, in two independent real-world prenatal cohorts. The system was compared against three existing methods: Xrare, Exomiser, and PhenIX. The primary performance metric was the ranking of diagnostic variants, with Berrylyzer ranking 56.41% and 58.12% of variants first in the two cohorts. Its recall rates within the top 20 ranked variants were 94.02% and 97.42%, respectively.
Berrylyzer outperformed the comparator tools in recall rates within the top 20. For the two cohorts, its performance (94.02%/97.42%) was higher than Xrare (85.19%/87.08%), Exomiser (84.90%/85.98%), and PhenIX (82.05%/88.93%). The analysis also indicated robust performance across diverse disease categories, inheritance patterns, and analytical strategies, with comparable results using both free-text phenotype descriptions and standardized terminologies.
Safety and tolerability data were not reported. Key limitations include the observational design, which precludes causal inference, and the lack of reported sample size, p-values, confidence intervals, and absolute numbers for the performance metrics. The study did not report on clinical outcomes, only on variant ranking performance.
The findings suggest Berrylyzer may be a practical tool for integration into clinical prenatal diagnostic pipelines, potentially advancing precision medicine in this setting. However, clinicians should interpret these results cautiously as they represent technical performance in specific cohorts and require prospective validation to confirm clinical utility and generalizability.
View Original Abstract ↓
Background: Artificial intelligence (AI)-driven variant prioritization has demonstrated substantial utility in expediting genetic diagnosis by ranking the most likely causative variants. While a variety of tools have been developed, few address the unique clinical and technical constraints in prenatal genetic diagnosis. Methods: We introduce Berrylyzer, a novel, end-to-end variant prioritization system applied to prenatal diagnosis.Inspired by clinician's reasoning process during variant interpretation, Berrylyzer applies a modular, stepwise scoring architecture that jointly integrates phenotypic and genomic evidence and delivers a ranked list of candidate variants, achieving high computational efficiency without compromising analytical rigor. Moreover, Berrylyzer natively supports both structured ontologies and free-text clinical narratives, enabling flexible integration into diverse clinical environments. Its performance was rigorously evaluated across two independent, real-world prenatal cohorts and benchmarked against three state-of-the-art methods: Xrare, Exomiser, and PhenIX. Results: Across the two datasets, Berrylyzer ranked 56.41% and 58.12% of diagnostic variants first, and achieved recall rates of 94.02% and 97.42% within top 20, respectively. Berrylyzer outperformed Xrare (85.19% and 87.08%), Exomiser (84.90% and 85.98%), and PhenIX (82.05% and 88.93%). Stratified analysis consistently demonstrated superior performance across diverse disease categories, inheritance patterns, and analytical strategies. Notably, Berrylyzer exhibited robustness regardless of phenotype forms, yielding comparable top 20 recall rates for free-text descriptions and standardized terminologies. Conclusion: Berrylyzer represents an accurate, interpretable, and computationally lightweight variant prioritization system for prenatal genetic diagnosis. The superior performance across heterogeneous diagnostic contexts enables it as a practical solution for seamless integration into clinical pipelines, thereby advancing precision medicine in prenatal settings.