A meta-analysis of 7 randomized trials looked at whether unstable resistance training (URT) using tools like balance boards or stability balls offers extra benefits for older adults compared with stable resistance training (SRT) like weight machines or free weights.
The review included older adults and compared short-term (10 to 12 weeks) and long-term (24 weeks) training. For lower limb strength and the Five-Times Sit-to-Stand test, URT did not outperform SRT. In fact, SRT showed a nonsignificant trend toward better performance on the sit-to-stand test.
However, URT did show two advantages: it significantly reduced fear of falling after short-term training, and it significantly improved Timed Up and Go performance (a measure of mobility) after long-term training compared with SRT.
The studies did not report any safety issues or side effects. Because the analysis combined small trials, the findings should be considered preliminary. The results suggest that adding unstable elements to resistance training might help older adults feel more confident and move better over time, but more research is needed.