Metagenomic sequencing reveals broader microbial detection than culture in biliary tract infections
This retrospective cohort study assessed patients with biliary tract infections to compare the breadth of microbial detection using metagenomic next-generation sequencing (mNGS) versus conventional microbiological techniques, including culture and smear microscopy. The primary outcome measured the breadth of microbial detection, while secondary outcomes included microbial profiles stratified by clinical variables, detection of specific bacterial taxa, and identification of anaerobes and polymicrobial signatures.
Results indicated that DNA-based mNGS showed broader microbial detection coverage than both RNA-based mNGS and conventional culture methods. Bacteria constituted the predominant component of detected organisms, with a considerable proportion of identified bacterial taxa being obligate or facultative anaerobes. Polymicrobial detection patterns were frequently observed. Commonly detected Gram-positive genera included Streptococcus and Enterococcus, while Gram-negative genera included Klebsiella and Escherichia.
Subgroup analyses revealed that male patients had higher detection rates of Enterococcus and Enterobacter compared to females. Additionally, Staphylococcus species were more frequently identified in gallbladder infections than in bile duct infections. The study noted inherent limitations of conventional microbiological methods as a key constraint. Safety data, including adverse events or tolerability, were not reported in the provided evidence.
The practice relevance suggests supporting the value of metagenomic sequencing for comprehensive microbial characterization in biliary tract infections. However, the complete spectrum of implicated pathogens may remain uncharacterized due to methodological constraints. Clinicians should consider these results as supportive rather than definitive proof of superiority, acknowledging the observational nature of the data.