Meta-analysis of NHPI populations shows low pooled Pap testing and HPV vaccine initiation rates with high treatment disparities.
This systematic review and meta-analysis examined cervical cancer prevention metrics, treatment disparities, and effective interventions specifically within Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander (NHPI) populations. The analysis synthesized data from 27 studies, though the specific setting and follow-up duration were not reported. The primary focus was on screening uptake, vaccination rates, and access to timely treatment.
The pooled rate for Pap testing was 62% (95% CI: 46%-75%), while the pooled rate for HPV vaccine initiation was 26% (95% CI: 16%-37%). Substantial heterogeneity was noted for both metrics, with I² values of 98.7% for Pap testing and 84.3% for HPV vaccine initiation, indicating considerable variability between the included studies. Regarding treatment, NHPI patients were less likely to receive timely and guideline-concordant cervical cancer treatment compared to other groups.
NHPI patients also exhibited higher rates of late-stage diagnoses and increased mortality. No specific adverse events, discontinuations, or tolerability data were reported for the interventions, as the review focused on disparities rather than drug safety. The study authors noted that findings on treatment and outcomes were based on narrative synthesis from studies unsuitable for quantitative meta-analysis, meaning specific effect sizes for these outcomes were not provided.
Key limitations include the substantial heterogeneity in pooled estimates and the reliance on observational data, which precludes causal conclusions. The practice relevance highlights that culturally tailored interventions and policies addressing systemic barriers are critical to reducing these inequities. Clinicians should interpret these pooled rates as estimates subject to significant variability across different healthcare contexts.