ED-based cervical cancer screening finds elevated abnormal Pap rates and high-risk HPV in trial participants
This randomized controlled trial evaluated test results and subsequent care among 181 women ages 21-65 who received cervical cancer screening within 365 days after enrollment in an ED-based intervention trial. The study examined two ED-based screening interventions, though specific comparators were not reported. Secondary outcomes included HPV infection rates, Pap test results, cervical cancer diagnoses, and subsequent care procedures.
Main results showed 12% of screened women had abnormal Pap test findings, which was statistically significantly elevated compared to a national rate of 3.8% (Z = 5.55, p < 0.001). High-risk HPV infection was present in 15% of those tested, which was elevated compared to an estimated nationwide prevalence of 11% though this difference approached but did not reach statistical significance (Z = 1.63, p = 0.052). Notably, nearly half of patients who required colposcopy and biopsy procedures lacked a routine women's health provider.
Safety and tolerability data were not reported. Key limitations include lack of data on subsequent clinical care, which limits appreciation of ED-based screening efforts. The study also did not provide absolute numbers for abnormal findings and HPV infections, and comparisons to national rates are observational rather than from randomized comparisons. While ED-based screening interventions demonstrated meaningful positive impact on subsequent testing and care in this trial, causation from screening to reduced mortality was not directly demonstrated. The findings highlight both the potential of ED screening to identify at-risk women and the challenges in ensuring appropriate follow-up care.