Narrative review suggests spontaneous-breathing anesthesia may offer cognitive protection in elderly surgical patients
A narrative review examined existing clinical evidence on the cognitive effects of spontaneous-breathing anesthesia versus conventional endotracheal intubation under general anesthesia in elderly surgical patients. The review population specifically focused on elderly patients, though sample size, specific surgical settings, and follow-up duration were not reported. The primary outcome of interest was cognitive protective effects, with no secondary outcomes specified.
The main finding was that existing clinical evidence indicates cognitive protective effects of spontaneous-breathing anesthesia in elderly patients during certain surgeries. However, no specific effect sizes, absolute numbers, p-values, or confidence intervals were reported for these protective effects. Safety and tolerability data, including adverse events, serious adverse events, and discontinuations, were not reported in the review.
Key limitations identified include heterogeneity in outcomes across different procedure types and methodological limitations in the studies reviewed. The authors note that the associated effects of spontaneous-breathing anesthesia remain inconclusive, and funding sources or potential conflicts of interest were not reported. While the review suggests this approach may provide guidance for perioperative brain health management in elderly patients, the evidence represents associations rather than proven causal benefits and should be interpreted with appropriate caution given the methodological constraints.