Mode
Text Size
Log in / Sign up

Multimodal and simulation-based training are identified interventions for improving hospital cleaning staff hand hygieneHand Hygiene Training for Hospital Cleaners Shows Limited Evidence

AI-generated summary of the cited source, checked by automated accuracy review. How we work

Key Takeaway
Note that evidence on hand hygiene among cleaning staff is currently limited and predominantly descriptive.

This scoping review analyzed 33 sources, including 5 guidelines, 25 full-text studies, and 3 conference abstracts, to evaluate hand hygiene among hospital cleaning staff in acute care hospitals. The review focused on attitudes, behaviors, knowledge, and practices related to hand hygiene, as well as the factors that promote or inhibit these behaviors.

The authors identified specific intervention types including target group-oriented training materials, simulation-based training, and multimodal approaches and training programs. These methods were highlighted as primary strategies for addressing hand hygiene among cleaning staff.

A significant limitation noted by the authors is that the available evidence is predominantly descriptive and limited in scope regarding this specific workforce. The review underscores a need for more methodologically diverse research to strengthen infection prevention protocols.

Clinically, these findings suggest that while multimodal and simulation-based training are identified as key strategies, the current body of evidence is not robust enough to establish definitive outcomes. Practice relevance lies in the need for targeted guidelines and specialized interventions tailored specifically to the needs of hospital cleaning staff.

A new review looked at how to improve hand hygiene among hospital cleaning staff, a group that plays a key role in preventing infections. The researchers searched for studies and found 33 sources, including guidelines and research papers, but the overall evidence was limited and mostly descriptive. This means we don't have strong proof about what works best.

The review identified some approaches that have been tried, such as training materials made for cleaning staff, simulation-based training, and programs that use multiple methods. However, the studies were not strong enough to show which of these are most effective. The review also noted that three conference abstracts were not included in the main analysis because they lacked full texts.

No safety concerns were reported in the studies, but that doesn't mean they were safe or unsafe. The main limitation is that the evidence is weak, so we can't draw firm conclusions. The researchers emphasize the need for better-designed studies and for developing specific guidelines and interventions for this group.

For readers, this review is a reminder that while hand hygiene is important, we need more research to know how to best support hospital cleaning staff. If you work in healthcare, talk to your infection control team about current best practices.

What this means for you:
More research is needed to find the best ways to improve hand hygiene among hospital cleaning staff.

Common questions

What did the review find about hand hygiene training for hospital cleaning staff?

The review found that the evidence on hand hygiene training for hospital cleaning staff is limited and mostly descriptive. It identified some approaches like training materials, simulation, and multimodal programs, but couldn't say which works best due to weak studies.

Why is hand hygiene important for hospital cleaning staff?

Hospital cleaning staff play a key role in preventing infections. Good hand hygiene helps stop the spread of germs. The review highlights the need for better research and targeted programs to support them, but doesn't provide specific advice.

What are the limitations of this review?

The main limitation is that the evidence is weak and mostly descriptive. Also, three conference abstracts were not included because they lacked full texts. So, the findings are not conclusive and more research is needed.

Study Details

Study typeSystematic review
EvidenceLevel 1
PublishedJul 2026
View Original Abstract ↓
ObjectivesThe aim of this study was to examine attitudes and behaviors related to hand hygiene among hospital cleaning staff and to identify promoting and inhibiting factors influencing hand hygiene behavior. In addition, existing worldwide target group-specific interventions for this occupational group were mapped.MethodsA comprehensive literature search was conducted for publications from 2009 to 2025 in MEDLINE (via PubMed®), the Cochrane Library, CINAHL (via EBSCO), Embase, and Scopus. Additional research was carried out in WHO IRIS, BASE, and Science.gov, and internationally applicable guidelines were identified using the TRIP Database. Included were studies from worldwide somatic acute care hospitals examining hand hygiene compliance, knowledge, attitudes, practices, influencing factors, or interventions among cleaning staff. Texts limited to other hygiene domains, airborne infections, non-acute-care settings, or study populations consisting of mixed occupational groups and not limited to cleaning staff exclusively were excluded. Literature screening was performed in two stages (title/abstract and full-text screening), and data extraction was conducted by one reviewer using a standardized extraction table.ResultsIn total, 33 sources met the inclusion criteria, comprising five guidelines, 25 full-text studies, and three conference abstracts, which formed the primary basis of this review. The conference abstracts identified during the research for which corresponding full texts were not provided were documented for the sake of completeness, but not included in the main analysis and qualitative synthesis, as relevant information may not be available due to the lack of full texts. The base of evidence was heterogeneous and predominantly descriptive, addressing knowledge, attitudes, practices, as well as promoting and inhibiting factors. Identified interventions related to infection prevention and control and hand hygiene among cleaning staff were based on the provision of target group-oriented training materials, simulation-based training, and multimodal approaches and training programs.ConclusionThe findings indicate overall limited and predominantly descriptive evidence regarding hand hygiene among hospital cleaning staff. This underscores the need for methodologically diverse research as well as the development of target group–specific interventions and guidelines to strengthen infection prevention, particularly hand hygiene, in acute care hospital settings.
Free Newsletter

Clinical research that matters. Delivered to your inbox.

Join thousands of clinicians and researchers. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.