Network meta-analysis compares risperidone and aripiprazole for autism irritability

Background A high proportion of autistic people receive off-license antipsychotic medication, often in the absence of a mental illness, primarily for behaviours that challenge, which is a public health concern. Although meta-analyses have been published recently, there is a lack of a comprehensive network meta-analysis to inform clinicians about the relative efficacy and safety of antipsychotic medications. Aims To conduct a network meta-analysis of available RCTs of antipsychotic medications involving autistic participants to assess the relative efficacy of different antipsychotics and their adverse effects. Method We searched seven databases and hand-searched ten relevant journals. Two authors independently screened titles, abstracts, and full papers, extracted data, and assessed their quality. Results We analysed data from 22 RCTs involving 1562 autistic people. The largest mean difference with 95% confidence interval in the Aberrant Behaviour Checklist-Irritability (ABC-I) score compared with placebo was from the combined intervention with risperidone and parent training: -11.16 (-15.13, -7.18), followed by risperidone: -7.59 (-9.22, -5.95), and aripiprazole: -5.59 (-7.18, -4). The largest effect on Clinical Global Impression-Improvement (CGI-I) scores was from risperidone, 7.65 (2.17, 27.04), followed by aripiprazole, 7.02 (1.92, 25.72), compared with placebo. Risperidone (4; 1.57, 10.21) and aripiprazole (2.77; 1.20, 6.39) had significantly higher odds ratios for adverse effects, but aripiprazole showed the least weight gain. Conclusions Combined parent training and risperidone followed by risperidone and aripiprazole showed the best effects on the ABC-I score, whereas risperidone and aripiprazole showed the greatest effect on the CGI-I score. However, risperidone and aripiprazole showed significantly increased adverse effects.