This observational research article examined meat samples from 50 beef and 46 lamb independent butchers in Wales, United Kingdom. The study population included 79 antibiotic-resistant (ABR) E. coli isolates from lamb meat, 92 from beef meat, and 352 faecal samples from sheep and 361 from beef cattle on Welsh farms. Additionally, 2387 ABR E. coli isolates from extraintestinal infections in people in a bordering English region were analyzed for comparison.
The primary exposure was the presence of ABR E. coli on the meat. Prevalence of resistance to amoxicillin was 31%, streptomycin 28%, spectinomycin 29%, amoxicillin-clavulanate 11%, fluoroquinolones 5%, and third-generation cephalosporins 2%. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that ABR E. coli isolates from Welsh lamb meat were more closely related to faecal samples collected around sheep than around beef cattle.
Regarding safety and public health implications, no closely related meat-infection clones were found between ABR E. coli from Welsh meat and those causing extraintestinal infections in people. The study did not report specific safety tolerability data or follow-up periods. Key limitations include the observational nature of the design, which precludes causal conclusions, and the lack of reported p-values or confidence intervals for the prevalence estimates. The relevance to clinical practice is restrained by the specific geographic setting and the absence of direct evidence linking these meat isolates to human disease outbreaks.
View Original Abstract ↓
Many studies have identified antibiotic resistant (ABR) Escherichia coli on meat. Appropriate hand hygiene and cooking practices should minimise the risk of gastrointestinal colonisation with ABR E. coli found on meat, and the subsequent chance of causing resistant opportunistic extraintestinal infection. There are large gaps in our understanding of the prevalence, origins and zoonotic potential of ABR E. coli found on meat, however, and particularly for meat reared in extensive farming systems. Wales is a devolved nation within the United Kingdom having large populations of extensively-reared sheep and beef cattle. To help address knowledge gaps around ABR E. coli on extensively reared meat, therefore, beef mince and lamb loin/leg steaks/chops were purchased from 50 (beef) and 46 (lamb) independent butchers across Wales. Following enrichment culture, 200 g meat samples were found to be positive for E. coli resistant to amoxicillin (31% positivity), streptomycin (28%), spectinomycin (29%), amoxicillin-clavulanate (11%), 3rd generation cephalosporins (2%) and fluoroquinolones (5%). Phylogenetic analysis confirmed that Welsh lamb meat ABR E. coli isolates (n=79) are more closely related to those found in faecal samples collected around sheep (n=352) than around beef cattle (n=361) on Welsh farms. This suggests that faecal contamination at or around slaughter is their primary origin. We found no closely related meat/infection clones (<20 SNPs distant and the same antibiotic resistance genes) when comparing ABR E. coli from Welsh meat (n=92) and those causing extraintestinal infections in people (n=2387) in an English region bordering Wales. We conclude, therefore, that the wider zoonotic implications of finding ABR E coli on beef and lamb meat sold at independent butchers in Wales are small.