Rare variants in 44 dystonia genes show no major contribution to Parkinson's disease risk overall.
This meta-analysis utilized whole-genome sequencing data from the Accelerating Medicines Partnership-PD and UK Biobank cohorts to assess the association of rare variants (minor allele frequency <1%) in 44 dystonia-related genes with Parkinson's disease. The study included 5,315 patients with Parkinson's disease, including 300 with early-onset disease, and 36,902 controls. The primary outcome evaluated the association of these rare variants with all Parkinson's disease cases and specifically with early-onset Parkinson's disease.
Regarding overall Parkinson's disease, several genes demonstrated nominal associations. Specifically, SQSTM1 (Ploss-of-function = 5.52 x 10-3), AOPEP (Pexonic = 6.96 x 10-3; Pnonsynonymous = 0.017), KCNA4 (Pexonic = 0.017), SPR (Pexonic = 0.029), SLC30A10 (PCADD≥20 = 0.046), and ACTB (Pexonic = 0.047) showed nominal significance. However, none of these associations remained statistically significant after correction for multiple testing.
For early-onset Parkinson's disease, five genes reached significance after multiple-test correction. The signal for GCH1 was nominally significant (Pnonsynonymous = 4.36 x 10-3, PFDR = 0.062). These signals were driven by small numbers of variant carriers and were not robust to leave-one-variant-out analyses. No safety data or adverse events were reported as this was a genetic association study rather than a clinical trial.
Key limitations include that signals in the early-onset subset were based on small numbers of variant carriers and require replication in larger cohorts. The study design was observational, assessing association rather than causation. Consequently, the genetic contribution of dystonia genes to overall Parkinson's disease risk does not appear major, and the robustness of early-onset findings remains uncertain pending further validation.