Systematic review finds online cleft care materials exceed recommended readability levels
Photo by Marek Studzinski / Unsplash
Key Takeaway
Note that online cleft care materials exceed recommended readability levels.
This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated online patient education materials for cleft care. The authors analyzed nine studies to determine if the text complexity aligns with recommended readability standards. The scope included materials for cleft lip and cleft palate care found in PubMed, Scopus, and Embase databases.
The pooled results indicate that the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level was 9.48 (95% CI: 8.51-10.45). The Flesch Reading Ease score averaged 52.98 (95% CI: 42.62-63.34). The SMOG Index yielded a result of 9.27 (95% CI: 5.97-12.57). The Gunning Fog Index result was 9.94 (95% CI: 8.90-10.98). All these metrics exceed recommendations.
Heterogeneity analysis showed an I² value of 0%. The authors noted that artificial intelligence tools lacked usability and comprehension testing. The review highlights that online patient education materials for cleft care are consistently written at reading levels too complex for the average caregiver.
The study did not report adverse events or discontinuations. Funding or conflicts were not reported. The authors caution against inferring causality from pooled readability estimates or assuming clinical outcomes from readability metrics. Improved readability and accessibility are needed for this patient population.
View Original Abstract ↓
ObjectiveTo evaluate the readability of online patient education materials (PEMs) for cleft lip and/or palate and assess their alignment with recommended readability levels.DesignThis study is a systematic review and meta-analysis.SettingLiterature search conducted in PubMed, Scopus, and Embase databases following PRISMA guidelines.MaterialsStudies evaluating online PEMs for cleft care with reported readability metrics, including Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level, Flesch Reading Ease, SMOG Index, or Gunning Fog Index.InterventionsAssessment of readability metrics of online PEMs and evaluation of artificial intelligence tools (eg, ChatGPT) for text simplification.Main Outcome Measure(s)Pooled readability estimates (eg, Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level, Flesch Reading Ease, SMOG Index, Gunning Fog Index), heterogeneity (I²), and confidence intervals (CIs).ResultsNine studies were included, consistently showing that PEMs exceed readability recommendations. Pooled estimates revealed a Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level of 9.48 (95% CI: 8.51-10.45), Flesch Reading Ease score of 52.98 (95% CI: 42.62-63.34), SMOG Index of 9.27 (95% CI: 5.97-12.57), and Gunning Fog Index of 9.94 (95% CI: 8.90-10.98). Heterogeneity was minimal (² = 0%). Artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT demonstrated potential in simplifying text to the recommended sixth-grade reading level but lacked usability and comprehension testing.ConclusionsOnline PEMs for cleft care are consistently written at reading levels too complex for the average caregiver, underscoring the need for improved readability and accessibility. Future research should focus on developing multimodal resources, conducting usability assessments, and including non-English materials to address global disparities in cleft care education.
Primary community health care nurses improve patient outcomes and reduce costs compared to medical practitioners
Meta-analysis shows primary care nurses improve health and save money compared to medical practitioners
Related in Primary Care & Family Medicine
CBT-based psychoeducation improves anger control and death anxiety in cancer patients receiving chemotherapy
Eight CBT sessions help cancer patients control anger and fear of death
This randomized controlled trial enrolled 80 individuals receiving chemotherapy, with 40 in the control group and 40 receiving eight session…
Eight sessions of CBT-based psychoeducation significantly improved anger control and reduced death anxiety in people receiving chemotherapy …
Multiple gender expressions in anti-smoking messages reduced perceived effectiveness among sexual and gender minority young adults
Anti-smoking ads with multiple gender expressions lowered perceived effectiveness in SGM young adults
This randomized online experiment involved 1,113 sexual and gender minority young adults. Participants viewed anti-smoking messages portrayi…
Ads showing multiple gender expressions were less effective than those showing masculine expressions among sexual and gender minority young …
Statistical framing increased screening intentions while narrative framing increased information-seeking in autism spectrum disorder
Statistical messages boost autism screening intentions
This randomized experiment examined how message type and framing affect behavioral intentions regarding autism spectrum disorder screening. …
Numbers may persuade parents to screen for autism, but stories drive information-seeking.
Text messaging plus educational materials improves healthy eating in uncontrolled diabetes
Text Messages Plus Education Improve Healthy Eating in Diabetes Care
This three-arm pragmatic randomized trial in 666 African-American adults with uncontrolled diabetes found that adding text messaging to educ…
A trial found that adding text messages to diabetes education helped participants eat healthier more often than education alone.
From Other Specialties
Meta-analysis links facial palsy and ANCA negativity to poor hearing in OMAAV patients
Three Signs Predict Hearing Loss In A Rare Vasculitis Disease
This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluates hearing outcomes in patients with otitis media associated with ANCA-associated vasculitis…
Three specific health markers predict hearing loss in patients with a rare form of ear inflammation, offering doctors a clearer path to prot…
GERD Associated with Increased Risk of Laryngeal Cancer in Meta-Analysis
Large study links GERD to higher risk of laryngeal cancer
A systematic review and meta-analysis of 1,768,394 adults found that gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) was significantly associated wit…
A massive analysis of nearly 1.8 million adults found a link between gastroesophageal reflux disease and increased risk of laryngeal cancer.
Forgiveness psychoeducation reduces death anxiety and burden in end-of-life caregivers over one to three months
Forgiveness training eases death anxiety in caregivers
This randomized controlled trial involved 56 caregivers of patients at the end of life. The experimental group received forgiveness psychoed…
A small trial found that forgiveness training helped caregivers of dying patients feel less anxious and burdened.
Nurse and social worker telecare team intervention improved quality of life in high-risk patients with COPD, heart failure, or interstitial lung disease.
Telecare Team Helps Heart And Lung Patients Feel Better For Less Cost
This randomized clinical trial evaluated a nurse and social worker telecare team intervention (ADAPT) in high-risk patients with chronic obs…
A simple phone call from a care team can significantly improve how patients feel and function while keeping costs low.