This narrative synthesis examines 59 articles regarding tubeless thoracic surgery, defined as non-intubated, spontaneous ventilation, and VATS, for patients with pulmonary nodules. The review scope includes perioperative outcomes such as pain, hospital stay, and laryngeal edema, as well as potential risks like intraoperative hypercapnia and the potential need for conversion to intubation.
The authors report reductions in pain, hospital stay, postoperative nausea and vomiting, and laryngeal edema. Conversely, the review identifies risks including intraoperative hypercapnia and the potential need for conversion to intubation. However, long-term oncological safety remains unconfirmed based on the available data.
The authors highlight limitations including the heterogeneous nature of the available evidence, the lack of a formal quality assessment, and the absence of a meta-analysis. They advise that direct comparisons should be interpreted with caution. Consequently, the practice relevance is restricted to carefully selected patients and experienced centers where tubeless technology may optimize perioperative management and enhance recovery.
View Original Abstract ↓
ObjectiveThis narrative review aims to summarize the current research progress on Tubeless thoracic surgery for pulmonary nodules, analyze its physiological basis and clinical applications, and outline future directions.MethodsA literature search was performed in PubMed and Web of Science from database inception to December 2025 using the following Boolean search string: (“Tubeless” OR “non-intubated” OR “spontaneous ventilation”) AND (“VATS” OR “video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery”) AND (“pulmonary nodules” OR “lung nodules” OR “GGN”). A total of 1,902 records were identified. After title and abstract screening independently by two authors, 59 articles were finally included. Eligible studies included randomized controlled trials, prospective and retrospective cohort studies, case series (n ≥ 10), and expert consensus statements. Only English-language articles were included, as the review is intended for an international readership. Given the heterogeneous nature of the available evidence, this review is presented as a narrative synthesis with no formal quality assessment or meta-analysis.Key findingsData from heterogeneous studies suggest reductions in laryngeal edema, postoperative nausea and vomiting, pain, and hospital stay, although direct comparisons should be interpreted with caution. However, risks include intraoperative hypercapnia and the potential need for conversion to intubation. Long-term oncological safety remains unconfirmed.ConclusionIn carefully selected patients and experienced centers, available evidence suggests that Tubeless technology may optimize perioperative management and enhance recovery after pulmonary nodule resection. Future efforts should focus on integrating electromagnetic navigation bronchoscopy, artificial intelligence for risk prediction, and day-surgery pathways to maximize clinical and economic benefits.