Arts on Prescription programmes show statistically significant but clinically modest reductions in depression and anxiety among adults
Photo by National Cancer Institute / Unsplash
Key Takeaway
Note clinically modest reductions in depression and anxiety with Arts on Prescription programmes.
This narrative synthesis examines community-based Arts on Prescription programmes where artistic activities are prescribed by health professionals. The review covers adults participating in these initiatives led by artists or musicians. The scope includes wellbeing as the primary outcome and depression and anxiety as secondary outcomes.
The analysis included 12 to 1,297 participants across community-based settings. Results indicate improvement in wellbeing was reported for the overall population. For depression and anxiety specifically, the authors note statistically significant but clinically modest reductions.
Important limitations include lack of control groups and small, non-representative samples. Follow-up periods were short, which restricts long-term conclusions. The authors state that evidence regarding depression and anxiety was limited to one study. Causality was not reported, and the certainty note highlights these constraints.
Practice relevance suggests potential benefits for depression and anxiety that warrant investigation in more rigorous study designs. Safety data such as adverse events or discontinuations were not reported. Clinicians should interpret these findings cautiously given the preliminary nature of the evidence.
More on Depression
Internet-based CBT modestly reduces anxiety and depression in breast cancer survivors
Internet therapy helps breast cancer survivors manage anxiety and depression
This meta-analysis of 1016 breast cancer survivors found that internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (I-CBT) significantly reduced anxi…
A large analysis found online cognitive behavioral therapy significantly reduced anxiety and depression in breast cancer survivors, offering…
Interventions reduce mental health symptoms in people affected by extreme weather events across multiple studies
Helpful actions reduce mental health problems after extreme weather events for many people
A comprehensive review of thirty-three studies reveals that targeted interventions significantly improve mental health outcomes for individu…
A review of thirty-three studies shows that specific actions help people feel better after disasters. These steps lower stress, sadness, and…
Structured exercise cuts depression, anxiety, and stress in university students with large to moderate effects
Structured Exercise Linked to Lower Depression, Anxiety, and Stress in Students
This systematic review and network meta-analysis of 2,127 university students found that structured exercise interventions were associated w…
A large review suggests structured exercise helps university students manage depression, anxiety, and stress better than doing nothing.
Depression screening predicts lower health-related quality of life in ICU survivors
Depression and anxiety symptoms lower health quality for ICU survivors after leaving the hospital
This cross-sectional analysis of pre-randomization data from a randomized controlled trial evaluated 319 intensive care unit survivors. Depr…
A study of 319 ICU survivors found that depression and anxiety symptoms significantly reduce health quality. Screening for these issues is i…
View Original Abstract ↓
IntroductionArts on Prescription is a social prescribing model in which health professionals refer adults to community-based artistic activities led by artists or musicians, with the goal of promoting wellbeing and mental health. This systematic review aimed to investigate whether Arts on Prescription improves wellbeing and reduces symptoms of depression and anxiety.MethodsPubMed, PsycINFO and Cochrane CENTRAL were searched in November 2024, following a previously developed search strategy. The selection of studies, quality assessment and data extraction were carried out independently by two authors. Disagreements were resolved by consensus. We included randomised control trials, quasi-experimental studies, observational studies and mixed-methods studies assessing the impact of art programmes prescribed by a health professional on adults’ wellbeing and symptoms of depression and anxiety. A narrative synthesis of the results was carried out.ResultsOf the 3,561 unique citations obtained, six studies met the inclusion criteria. Analysis of the reference lists of the included studies revealed two additional pertinent studies. Five of the studies were quasi-experimental studies and three were observational studies. The sample size ranged from 12 to 1,297 participants, with an average age ranging from 43 to over 80 years old. In all studies, an improvement in wellbeing was reported following participation in Arts on Prescription programmes. Evidence regarding depression and anxiety was limited to one study, which reported statistically significant but clinically modest reductions in both outcomes.DiscussionArts on Prescription programmes were consistently associated with improvements in wellbeing across a range of populations and settings. Preliminary evidence suggests potential benefits for depression and anxiety that warrant investigation in more rigorous study designs. Further studies are needed to overcome the limitations of the analysed studies, such as the lack of control groups, small and non-representative samples, and short follow-up periods.Systematic review registrationhttps://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/view/CRD42024572685, identifier CRD42024572685
Primary community health care nurses improve patient outcomes and reduce costs compared to medical practitioners
Meta-analysis shows primary care nurses improve health and save money compared to medical practitioners
Related in Primary Care & Family Medicine
AI and digitalization associate with psychosocial risks and uneven impacts on adult workers in occupational environments
AI and digital work tools link to stress, burnout, and job insecurity for adult workers
This scoping review synthesizes evidence from 43 sources regarding artificial intelligence and work digitalization in adult workers. The aut…
A review of 43 sources shows AI and digital tools often bring stress, burnout, and job insecurity to adult workers, though training can help…
AI chatbot interaction improves patient perceptions of pharmacist roles in a pilot study
AI chatbots improved how patients feel about asking pharmacists questions
This pilot randomized controlled trial enrolled 280 participants on a crowdsourcing platform. Participants interacting with an AI chatbot pr…
A pilot study with 280 people found that talking to an AI chatbot made them more comfortable asking pharmacists questions and trusting their…
Mental Health Literacy Curriculum Improves Outcomes in Chinese College Students
A simple three-month class improved mental health knowledge and reduced depression risk for Chinese college students
A 3-month mental health literacy curriculum improved literacy, life satisfaction, and resilience in Chinese college students, and prevented …
A three-month mental health literacy class helped Chinese college students feel more satisfied and resilient while keeping depression levels…
Non-surgical weight loss reduces AHI by 11.10 in adults with obstructive sleep apnoea
Non-surgical weight loss lowers sleep apnea severity and blood pressure in adults
This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated non-surgical weight loss interventions in adults with obstructive sleep apnoea. The poole…
Non-surgical weight loss significantly reduced sleep apnea severity and blood pressure in adults, though long-term results remain uncertain.
From Other Specialties
Metabolic syndrome linked to higher risk of several obesity-related cancers and worse colorectal cancer survival
Metabolic Syndrome Raises Cancer Risk And Worsens Survival For Some Patients
An umbrella review of 21 systematic reviews with meta-analyses found suggestive evidence that metabolic syndrome increases the risk of sever…
A big review found that metabolic syndrome makes obesity-related cancers more likely and can hurt survival chances. Doctors say fixing this …
Gut microbes and metabolites may influence aging, though human evidence remains limited
Gut microbes may influence aging, but human evidence remains limited
This narrative review examines the role of gut microbes and their metabolites in aging. The authors note that most evidence comes from anima…
A review suggests gut microbes might affect aging, yet most data comes from animals and direct human proof is still missing.
Intercostal nerve cryoablation reduces length of stay by 2.2 days in pediatric pectus excavatum surgery compared to standard care
Ice on nerves shortens hospital stays for chest wall surgery in children
This systematic review and meta-analysis evaluated intercostal nerve cryoablation versus standard multimodal analgesia in 922 pediatric pati…
A new analysis of 922 children shows ice on chest nerves cuts hospital time by two days while keeping pain levels the same as standard care.
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation cuts neuropathic pain intensity with large effect in meta-analysis
Magnetic brain stimulation eases nerve pain, review finds
This meta-analysis of 435 patients with peripheral neuropathic pain found that repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS) significa…
For people with nerve pain, a treatment using magnetic pulses on the brain may cut pain intensity, a new review of 435 patients shows.